top of page

Carriers, Claims & Payments

With access to several of the largest and most respected companies, we are confident we can find the best coverage and rates for you.

Use the links below to see more information about a company. Many of the companies we represent offer online claims service and bill pay.

Auto-Owners Logo

Auto-Owners Insurance

Phone:

800.346.0346

Claims:

888.252.4626

American Modern Logo

American Modern

Phone:

855.469.2644

Claims:

800.375.2075

Foremost Insurance Logo

Foremost Insurance Group

Phone:

800.527.3905

Claims:

800.527.3905

Hanover Insurance Group Logo

Hanover Insurance Group

Phone:

800.922.8427

Claims:

800.628.0250

Indiana Farmers Insuarance Logo

Indiana Farmers Insurance

Phone:

800.666.6460

Claims:

800.477.1660

Progressive Insurance Logo

Progressive Insurance

Phone:

888.671.4405

Claims:

800.776.4737

 Rockford Mutual Insurance Logo

Rockford Mutual Insurance Company

Claims:

800.747.7642

Safeco Insurance Logo

Safeco Insurance

Phone:

800.332.3226

Claims:

800.332.3226

State Auto Logo

State Auto

Phone:

614.464.5000

Claims:

800.766.1853

In need of insurance in Indiana?
Get a free quote! 
Henthorn Agency, Inc.

411 Main Street
Beech Grove, Indiana 46107
Phone: 317-787-9489
Fax: 317-787-9480

Henthorn Sappenfield Agency, LLC

60 W Churchmen Avenue
Beech Grove, Indiana 46107
Phone: 317-788-9931

©

2025

Henthorn Agency, Inc.  |  All Rights Reserved  |  Privacy Policy

bottom of page